BREAKINGCrude Oil prices remain stable amid supply concerns and geopolitical tensions

Crypto exchanges: Industry experts call for separation of trading and custody

Industry experts are urging crypto exchanges to split trading operations from asset custody, a move aimed at cutting systemic risk and mirroring long‑standing practices in traditional finance.

DIGITAL ASSETSCRYPTOFXROLL
60-second read
  • Darren Jordan of Komainu and other specialists call for a clear divide between trading platforms and custodial vaults.
  • Keeping client funds inside the same system that runs trades creates a single point of failure, especially after recent exchange hacks.
  • Traditional markets keep trade execution and asset holding separate to protect investors from insolvency or cyber attacks.

Digital‑asset platforms are under fresh pressure to change how they hold client money. A group of industry specialists, led by Darren Jordan of the custodian Komainu, argue that trading venues should no longer keep user funds in the same environment where orders are matched. The proposal aims to lower the chance that a breach or technical glitch wipes out billions of dollars in seconds, and it follows a pattern of failures that have shaken confidence in centralized exchanges.

Why the split matters now

When a security incident hits a crypto exchange, the same system often stores the assets that traders have deposited. That design means a single breach can give attackers access to the entire pool of user balances. Recent high‑profile collapses and large‑scale hacks have demonstrated how quickly large sums can disappear, leaving thousands of retail participants with little recourse. By moving assets to an independent, regulated custodian, an exchange can isolate its trading engine from the vault that holds the money. If the trading front end goes down, the funds remain protected in a separate legal entity.

How traditional finance handles the issue

In stock or commodity markets, the firm that executes a trade is rarely the one that physically holds the underlying securities. Brokers and dealers act as intermediaries, while specialised custodians keep the assets in segregated accounts. This separation was introduced to protect investors if a brokerage becomes insolvent or suffers a cyber attack. The model also allows regulators to monitor custody providers more closely, ensuring that client assets are ring‑fenced from operational risk.

Recent events that raised the alarm

The crypto sector has historically combined the roles of marketplace and custodian. In the early days of digital assets, many exchanges offered a one‑stop shop where users could trade and store their coins. Over the past few years, several exchanges have collapsed after losing access to their own wallets, and major hacks have stolen user balances in a matter of minutes. Those incidents have sparked a debate about whether the industry should continue to rely on a single‑entity model or adopt the split‑custody approach used by banks and broker‑dealers.

What to watch in the coming months

Regulators in several jurisdictions have started to ask exchanges about their custody arrangements. Some are drafting rules that would require clear segregation of client assets from the exchange's own balance sheet. At the same time, third‑party custodians are expanding services tailored to crypto firms, offering insurance and compliance frameworks that match traditional standards. Traders should keep an eye on announcements from their preferred platforms regarding segregated accounts, independent custody solutions, and any changes to fee structures that may result from partnering with external custodians.

What it means for traders

For market participants, the push for separation could bring both benefits and new considerations. Greater protection of funds may increase confidence, especially for institutional players who demand high security standards. On the downside, using an external custodian could add steps to the deposit and withdrawal process, and fees might rise to cover the cost of specialised storage and insurance. Traders should review whether their exchange offers a segregated account option and understand how that arrangement affects the speed and cost of moving assets in and out of the platform.

Frequently asked questions

What is custody in the crypto context?

Custody refers to the service of holding digital assets on behalf of clients, usually in secure, offline storage that is separate from the trading system.

Why does separating trading and custody reduce risk?

If the trading platform is compromised, the assets stored in a different legal entity remain out of reach, preventing a single breach from draining all user balances.

Will I have to pay more for this service?

External custodians charge fees for secure storage and insurance, so some exchanges may pass those costs onto users, but the exact impact will vary by platform.

Risk warning: Trading foreign exchange and CFDs on margin carries a high level of risk and may not be suitable for all investors. Leverage can work against you. Content on FXROLL is for information and education only and is not investment advice. Prices and data may be delayed or contain errors.

Keep reading

More news →