HSBC says gold should not be relied on to cushion a portfolio when stocks fall suddenly. In recent sell-offs, investors who borrowed to trade have had to sell gold to cover margin calls, which are demands to add cash when losses mount. That selling has dragged gold lower at the same time as shares.
The timing fits Thursday's market. Spot gold dropped to around $4,040 to $4,050 an ounce, its lowest level since August and about a quarter below its January peak, while the Nasdaq fell more than 2.5% in a broad sell-off in chip stocks. Earlier this year gold traded well above $5,000 before stalling.
The bank still sees a lasting place for gold in portfolios. It points to three long-term forces: worries about government debt and inflation eroding the value of money, central banks moving more of their reserves into gold, and a world splitting into rival political and trade blocs. HSBC said gold can be a good hedge against risks to the whole financial system, but cannot be counted on to reduce short-term swings. Its advice is to spread money across several assets, because no single one protects against every kind of stress.