BREAKINGUSDJPY and XAUUSD react as US carrier arrives in Middle East amid Iran tensions

MT4 vs MT5: what really differs and which one suits you

MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5 look almost the same, but they handle positions, tools and automated strategies differently. Here is what actually changes for a retail forex trader, with one worked example and a checklist before you choose.

BROKERSMARKETSFXROLL
60-second read
  • MT5 is not simply a newer MT4. It is a separate platform, and accounts, indicators and expert advisors do not move across between them.
  • The biggest practical difference is how positions are recorded, because MT5 accounts can run in hedging mode or netting mode.
  • MT5 adds more timeframes, more pending order types and more asset classes, but most forex beginners will not notice the gap at first.
  • Custom indicators and robots written for MT4 must be rewritten or replaced to run on MT5.
  • The platform matters less than the broker behind it, so check regulation, costs and execution before you worry about the software.

If you open an account with a forex broker, there is a good chance you will be offered MetaTrader. And then comes the first small puzzle: MT4 or MT5?

The two platforms look so alike that many traders assume MT5 is just an upgrade, like a new version of a phone app. It is not. They are two separate programs from the same developer, MetaQuotes, built on different code. Your choice decides which tools you can use, how your trades are shown and whether the indicators or robots you have collected will work.

The good news is that the differences that matter to most retail traders are few. Here they are, in plain English.

Where the two platforms came from

MT4 was built mainly for forex and contracts for difference. It became the standard retail platform because it was simple, ran on modest computers and let traders add custom indicators and automated strategies, known as expert advisors or EAs.

MT5 came later and was designed to handle more markets, including exchange-traded instruments such as shares and futures where a broker offers them. To do that, it had to change some basic rules about how positions are recorded. That is why it is a separate platform rather than an update.

In recent years MetaQuotes has steered the industry towards MT5, and more brokers now offer MT5 only, or MT5 first. MT4 is still widely available at many brokers, but if you are starting from scratch, check which one your broker plans to support over the long term.

The difference that matters most: hedging and netting

On MT4, every trade you open is its own separate position. Buy one lot of EUR/USD, then sell half a lot of EUR/USD, and you will see two open positions side by side: one long, one short.

MT5 accounts can be set up in one of two ways, and the broker chooses which.

  • Hedging mode works like MT4. Each trade stays as its own position, even when you hold both a buy and a sell on the same pair.
  • Netting mode keeps only one position per instrument. New trades are added to or taken away from it, and you see a single net figure.

Most forex brokers offering MT5 to retail clients use hedging mode, because traders are used to it. But netting mode exists, and if you land on a netting account without knowing it, your trade list can look very confusing.

A worked example

Let us use round, illustrative numbers. Say EUR/USD is at 1.1000 and you buy 1.0 lot. Later, the price is at 1.1050 and you decide to sell 0.5 lots, perhaps to lock in part of a move.

On MT4, or MT5 in hedging mode, you now hold two positions: 1.0 lot long from 1.1000 and 0.5 lots short from 1.1050. Each has its own stop-loss, take-profit and swap. You close them separately. Your exposure is effectively 0.5 lots long, but the platform shows both legs, and both may be charged overnight swap and spread.

On MT5 in netting mode, the 0.5-lot sell reduces your existing position. You are left with a single 0.5-lot long position, and the closed half is booked as a realised result. There is only one stop-loss and one take-profit for the whole position.

Neither approach is better in itself. But the habits differ. A hedging-style trader who likes to open opposite trades as a kind of temporary pause will find that impossible in netting mode. A trader who prefers one clean position per pair may find netting simpler. Before you trade, open a demo account and place a small buy and sell on the same pair to see which mode you are on.

Other differences you will notice

Beyond position handling, the main changes are about tools.

  • Timeframes. MT4 offers nine chart timeframes, from one minute to monthly. MT5 has many more, including in-between ones such as two-hour and twelve-hour charts. Useful if you like unusual timeframes, but most traders stick to the standard ones.
  • Pending orders. MT5 adds stop-limit orders on top of the usual buy and sell limits and stops. That gives a little more control over how an order is placed once a level is hit.
  • Market depth and built-in tools. MT5 includes a depth of market window and a built-in economic calendar. How useful depth of market is in forex depends on the broker, because retail forex prices usually come from the broker's own feed rather than one central exchange. You can also use the FXROLL economic calendar alongside either platform.
  • Strategy tester. Both let you test an expert advisor on past data, but MT5's tester is faster and can test across several symbols at once.
  • Asset range. Depending on the broker, MT5 may give access to more instrument types. On MT4, the range is mostly forex, metals, indices and commodity CFDs.

Indicators and robots do not carry over

This is the point that catches many people out. MT4 uses a programming language called MQL4. MT5 uses MQL5. A custom indicator or EA written for one will not run on the other.

If you have bought or downloaded tools for MT4, you will need MT5 versions of them, which may or may not exist. If you are about to buy an EA, check which platform it was written for, and be wary of any seller promising steady profits. Past test results on historical data can look far better than live trading, especially once spreads, slippage and swaps are included.

Accounts do not move across either. An MT4 account and an MT5 account are separate, even at the same broker, and you cannot open an MT4 account in the MT5 app.

The platform is not the broker

It is easy to spend hours comparing platforms when the bigger question is who holds your money. MetaTrader is software. The prices, spreads, execution and safety of your funds all come from the broker that runs it.

Two brokers on the same MT5 build can offer very different trading conditions. Before choosing, compare their licences, costs and withdrawal record in the FXROLL broker directory. If you are taking a funded challenge, check which platforms each firm supports on the prop firms page, because some offer only one.

Whatever platform you use, the risk side does not change. Size each trade from your stop-loss and your account, not from what the margin allows. The position size calculator and the pip value calculator work the same for either.

In practice

  • Ask your broker which platform it supports long term, and whether MT4 is still open to new clients.
  • On MT5, check whether your account is in hedging or netting mode before your first live trade.
  • Try both on a demo account and place a small opposite trade to see how positions are shown.
  • List any custom indicators or EAs you rely on and confirm an MT5 version exists before switching.
  • Do not choose a broker for its platform alone. Check its regulation, costs and execution first.
  • Keep your risk per trade the same whichever platform you use. New software is not a reason to trade bigger.

Risk warning: Trading foreign exchange and CFDs on margin carries a high level of risk and may not be suitable for all investors. Leverage can work against you. Content on FXROLL is for information and education only and is not investment advice. Prices and data may be delayed or contain errors.

Keep reading

More blog →