The moment you open a forex trade, you are already slightly behind. That is not bad luck. It is the price of doing business, and it is paid in three ways: the spread, the commission and the swap. None of them is large on its own, but together they decide whether a strategy that looks profitable on a chart is profitable in your account.
The good news is that all three are predictable. Once you can work them out for a single trade, you can compare brokers properly and avoid strategies that only make money for the platform.
The spread: the cost you see straight away
Every currency pair has two prices. The bid is what the market will pay you if you sell, and the ask is what you pay if you buy. The gap between them is the spread, and it is measured in pips.
Say EUR/USD shows 1.10000 / 1.10010. The spread is 1.0 pip. If you buy and immediately sell, you lose that pip. On one standard lot (100,000 units) of EUR/USD, a pip is worth about $10, so the spread costs you roughly $10 before the price has moved at all.
Spreads are not fixed. They tend to be tightest on the major pairs during the busiest hours, when London and New York are both open, and they widen around big news releases, at the daily rollover, and on thinly traded pairs. A pair that shows 0.8 pips at lunchtime in London can show several pips just after a central bank decision.
Commission: the cost some accounts add
Many brokers offer two account types. A standard account builds its fee into a wider spread and charges no commission. A raw or ECN account passes on a much tighter market spread and charges a separate commission per lot instead.
Commissions are usually quoted per lot, either per side (when you open and again when you close) or round turn (both together). Read which one it is. A "$3.50 per side" charge and a "$7 round turn" charge are the same thing.
Neither model is automatically cheaper. A raw account at 0.1 pips plus $7 round turn costs about $8 per lot on EUR/USD. A standard account at 1.0 pip with no commission costs about $10. A standard account at 1.6 pips costs about $16. You only know which is better by adding it up.
Swap: the cost of holding overnight
If you keep a position open past the broker's daily rollover (usually 5pm New York time), you pay or receive a swap, also called rollover or overnight financing.
Behind the scenes you are borrowing one currency to hold another, so the swap reflects the gap between their interest rates, minus the broker's markup. Holding the higher-yielding currency can earn a small credit; holding the lower-yielding one usually costs you. In practice the markup means many positions pay swap in both directions.
Two details catch people out. First, swap is often charged three times on one night of the week (commonly Wednesday) to cover the weekend. Second, swap is small per night but adds up over weeks. A position you meant to hold for a day that turns into a month can quietly lose a meaningful amount to financing. Our swap calculator shows the figure for your size and holding period.
One trade, all three costs
Here is a worked example with round, illustrative numbers. You buy 2 standard lots of EUR/USD on a raw account and hold the trade for three nights, one of which is the triple-swap night.
- Spread: 0.2 pips × $10 per pip × 2 lots = $4
- Commission: $7 round turn × 2 lots = $14
- Swap: say $6 per lot per night, for 5 charged nights (two normal nights plus one triple night) × 2 lots = $60
Total cost: about $78. If your target on this trade was 20 pips ($400 on 2 lots), costs take nearly a fifth of the profit. If your target was 5 pips ($100), costs would take most of it. That is the key lesson: costs are fixed per lot, so they matter far more when your targets are small.
Why this matters more than it seems
A scalper who places ten trades a day aiming for a few pips each is paying the spread and commission ten times. A small difference in cost per lot, multiplied across hundreds of trades a month, can be the whole difference between a winning and a losing record.
A swing trader who holds for weeks cares less about the spread and much more about swap. And anyone trading around news releases should expect the spread at that moment to be far wider than the advertised "from" figure.
How to keep costs down
- Compare brokers on total cost per lot (spread plus commission) for the pairs you actually trade, at the times you actually trade.
- Treat advertised "spreads from 0.0" as a best case, not a typical one. Look for average spreads if the broker publishes them.
- Check the swap rates in the platform before you hold anything overnight, especially for exotic pairs.
- Avoid opening trades in the minutes around major releases or the daily rollover, when spreads are widest.
- Size every trade from your risk, not your hopes. The position size calculator does it in seconds, and the pip value calculator shows what each pip is worth.
In practice
Before your next trade, write down three numbers: the spread in pips, the commission per lot, and the swap per night if you might hold it. Multiply by your lot size. If that total is a large share of your target, the trade needs a bigger target, a cheaper account, or a pass.
When you are choosing where to trade, our broker directory lists account types, regulators and costs side by side. And if any term here is new, the glossary explains it in plain English.
This article is for education only and is not investment advice. Trading forex on margin carries a high level of risk.
Risk warning: Trading foreign exchange and CFDs on margin carries a high level of risk and may not be suitable for all investors. Leverage can work against you. Content on FXROLL is for information and education only and is not investment advice. Prices and data may be delayed or contain errors.